Rare Game Condition Grading: CIB, Sealed, Loose (A Practical Standard)

Most collector disputes happen because condition words are vague. This guide defines a practical standard you can use for buying, selling, and building a shelf you trust.

Core Terms (Simple)

• Sealed: unopened, original wrap intact.
• CIB (Complete in Box): game + box + manual (and required inserts if expected).
• Loose: cartridge/disc only.

What Actually Drives Value

• Completeness (missing manuals/inserts matter).
• Label and print clarity (tears, fading, stains).
• Structural integrity (cracks, hinges, crushed corners).
• Authenticity and provenance (what you can verify).
• Honesty of description (vague listings are risk).

Sealed Grading (Practical)

• Display Grade: clean wrap, minimal corner wear, no major dents.
• Shelf Grade: minor dents or corner wear, still looks good.
• Damaged: tears, heavy dents, crushed corners, water damage, obvious rewrap risk.

CIB Grading (Box + Manual + Game)

• Clean: sharp edges, clean print, manual intact, minimal shelf wear.
• Used: visible wear, small tears or scuffs, still presentable.
• Rough: crushed corners, stains, heavy tears, missing parts.

Loose Grading (Cartridge/Disc Only)

• Label quality (peeling, fading, residue).
• Shell integrity (cracks, deep scratches).
• Contacts/disc surface (cleanliness, deep damage risk).

The Listing Standard (Copy/Paste Template)

• Type: Sealed / CIB / Loose
• Condition tier: Display / Shelf / Damaged (or Clean / Used / Rough)
• Completeness: list what’s included
• Notes: any tears, dents, stains, cracks
• Proof: clear photos of front/back/spine/inside (if CIB)

Buying Without Regret

1. Set a max price for each condition tier.
2. Avoid vague words without proof.
3. Prefer honest wear over hidden damage.
4. Buy meaning first, then condition.

Condition is culture. A good standard keeps collecting calm, fair, and fun.